Income, medical loss ratios, and the possession construction of Medicare Benefit plans


There’s quite a lot of controversy and uncertainty concerning earnings within the Medicare Benefit (MA) program. Curiosity in these points is rising because the share of beneficiaries grows. The Medicare Cost Advisory Fee, or MedPAC, not too long ago reported that MA enrollment grew 10% from July 2020 to July 2021. This implies MA accounted for 46% of all Medicare beneficiaries in 2021, with funds to MA plans totaling $350 billion. A current seen trade of details and interpretations of some knowledge by Berwick and Gilfillan, Halvorson,  Crane, and Ginsburg and Lieberman has highlighted how incomplete current knowledge are and the way that limits the power to reach at conclusions about market efficiency. The controversy is targeted on whether or not MA plans are “overpaid” and the diploma to which present regulatory preparations are prone to constrain potential overpayments. The priority is that MedPAC stories that MA plans proceed to be paid 104% of conventional Medicare Charge for Service (FFS) prices, and fee benchmarks stay at 108% of conventional Medicare FFS spending. Since 2010 and the enactment of the Reasonably priced Care Act (ACA), Medicare Half C or MA coverage has aimed to enhance alignment of plan prices and funds, partly by requiring that well being plans in MA attain a Medical Loss Ratio (the share of premiums spent on medical care) of 0.85.[1] The ACA additionally lowered some funds to MA plans. Collectively these coverage modifications sought to cut back overpayments that had been beforehand documented. On the time, the Congressional Price range Workplace (CBO) and the Medicare actuary predicted massive scale exit from MA markets. The precise expertise has been fairly totally different with robust market entry, and Safety Change Fee (SEC) filings and earnings stories counsel that MA was the supply of earnings development for a number of massive insurers (e.g., UnitedHealthcare, Humana). MA is now projected to enroll 50% of Medicare beneficiaries by 2025 or sooner.

The MA fee construction permits for a number of methods for plans to earn earnings. MA plans are paid based mostly on annual premium bids made towards a market benchmark that’s set administratively by the Facilities for Medicare and Medicaid Providers (CMS) underneath statutory authority and relies upon partly on the standard score achieved by a plan. That bid serves to ascertain plan revenues. The distinction between these revenues and incurred prices are plan earnings. A portion of the distinction between plan bids and the market benchmark is returned to the plan within the type of a “rebate” (or a type of shared financial savings). That rebate should be used to offer further advantages to beneficiaries that may entail lowered value sharing, decrease premiums, or supplemental advantages like imaginative and prescient, listening to, and dental companies. The projected premium for the supplemental profit related to the rebate is predicated on an actuarial estimate, and thus variations between the projected premium and precise prices are earnings. The Medical Loss Ratio (MLR) necessities for MA plans require that the distinction between revenues and medical prices can’t exceed 15% of complete revenues. As well as, non-compulsory supplemental advantages (distinct from the obligatory supplemental advantages related to rebates) might be provided by MA plans at a value to beneficiaries. Roughly 38% of plans provide such advantages. A plan’s margin for these non-compulsory supplemental advantages should be lower than 15% of premiums. The plan’s margin plus the executive prices of the profit should be lower than 30% of the premium.

MedPAC stories MA plan margins had been roughly 5% in 2019, and these different significantly by plan kind (e.g., Particular Wants Plans) and plan possession. MedPAC and others have famous that bids are more and more low with 87% of bids coming in at lower than conventional Medicare FFS spending; but plan funds stay at about 104% of conventional Medicare spending. Interpretation of those stories is difficult. Internet working revenue margins of 5% are nicely underneath the typical throughout industries. In contemplating these figures it is very important acknowledge that the overall income per enrollee represents a considerably greater base than that present in industrial insurance coverage, and that these revenues consist largely of taxpayer {dollars}. Margins is usually a deceptive indicator of profitability, particularly in excessive quantity industries. For instance, UnitedHealth Group enrolled practically 7.3 million folks. As well as, assessing different commonplace monetary efficiency ratios might be troublesome since a lot of the massive insurers that take part within the MA program promote to a number of insurance coverage markets and personal a wide range of associated and unrelated companies. Thus, allocating belongings to strains of companies to calculate different markers of monetary efficiency equivalent to returns on belongings (ROA), in lots of instances, requires considerably arbitrary assumptions or knowledge that aren’t publicly accessible.

On this paper, we look at sources of earnings and earnings by MA plans. We give attention to potential sources of earnings, the measurement challenges in monitoring profitability, and the function that MLR laws have in constraining the potential for overpayments. Whereas we acknowledge funding earnings is usually a vital supply of earnings, we don’t give attention to that supply on this evaluation. We give attention to guardian corporations and never particular person plans. We illustrate our factors by interesting to a mix of program broad data on gross earnings and margins, and case research the place extra full data is out there. Particularly, we illustrate a few of our factors utilizing examples from SEC 10-Ok and IRS Type 990 filings from Humana and Kaiser, two massive MA plan guardian corporations. We complement their publicly reported monetary efficiency metrics with our personal calculations of MA plan efficiency utilizing knowledge from Mark Farrah Associates. We spotlight the variations between the generally reported margin estimates of profitability and ROA. We additionally clarify the restricted means to calculate ROA.

Whereas we acknowledge the significance of coding as a supply of “overpayments” in MA, our focus will likely be largely on different dimensions of potential earnings which have obtained much less consideration. It is because the potential for some overpayments resulting from upcoding has been nicely established by MedPAC and Jacobs and Kronick. Nevertheless, acquiring a exact estimate of overpayments that distinguishes official coding from “upcoding” is difficult. Up to now, inferences about “upcoding” have been made by evaluating the diagnoses reported in conventional Medicare claims to these reported by MA plans. Separating official from illegitimate codes by means of this methodology is troublesome. Some proof reported in authorized actions and investigations of chart evaluation processes are higher positioned to uncover such variations however haven’t been utilized on a scientific foundation throughout this system.

The ACA reforms to Medicare Benefit and makes an attempt to cut back overpayments

The ACA contained a number of provisions that affected funds to MA plans. The ACA initially froze the extent of the benchmark towards which MA plans bid at 2010 ranges. Then, in 2012, the federal government started decreasing the benchmark to MA plans to extra intently align them with the price of offering Medicare Half A and B companies in conventional Medicare. Efforts had been additionally made to take account of geographic variation in spending by adjusting fee in keeping with the quartile of the spending distribution an space falls into. The ACA additionally imposed an MLR requirement of 0.85 to enhance alignment of plan “prices” and funds. If a plan’s MLR was repeatedly decrease than 0.85, a plan may very well be topic to sanctions. The trade between Berwick and Gilfillan, and Halvorson differed partly on the potential for overpayments based mostly on the effectiveness of the MLR necessities. Halvorson argued that the MLR was binding, whereas Berwick and Gilfillan, and Ginsburg and Lieberman expressed skepticism in regards to the energy of MLR to constrain overpayments.

Quite a lot of issues have been raised concerning the diploma to which MLR guidelines constrain earnings—these are linked to both the disguise of earnings as prices or to prices from plan purchases from associated companies producing earnings to the guardian firm that aren’t topic to MLR laws. As famous earlier, the priority about earnings disguised as prices has most incessantly been made with respect to “danger adjustment” coding. Not too long ago, the Inspector Common of the Division of Well being and Human Providers raised particular issues about coding practices, suggesting vital sums had been concerned. We won’t provide extra dialogue on this subject because of the beforehand talked about difficulties in making inferences about inappropriate coding.

MA can present supplemental advantages that aren’t lined underneath conventional Medicare. Examples embrace imaginative and prescient care companies, dental care, listening to exams and aids, and wellness applications. The prices of offering these further advantages are generally paid for utilizing “rebate” {dollars} that stem from the distinction between the premium bid and the benchmark value in a market established by Medicare. These advantages and revenue margins are included as a part of the calculation made as a part of the MLR evaluation. The margins from supplemental advantages paid by means of rebates additionally contribute to earnings and the general MLR calculation. The small print of utilization and spending related to these supplemental advantages are usually not nicely understood as the info on these parameters are usually not made public. Rebates account for about 15% of MA funds.

The businesses which have the biggest MA enrollments are massive medical insurance carriers: United, Humana, and Kaiser. In 2021, about 67% of enrollment in MA was accounted for by 5 massive insurers: United, Humana, CVS/Aetna, Kaiser, and Anthem. These corporations usually have just a few associated companies that present at the very least some companies to their MA plans. For instance, Humana owns a part of “Kindred at Dwelling,” a house well being and hospice supplier. Likewise, Kaiser owns Kaiser Basis Hospitals and the Permanente Medical Teams that each one contract with Kaiser MA plans. CVS/Aetna, United, and Cigna all personal PBMs that contract with their MA plans. Different companies embrace doctor practices, pharmacies, ambulances, and dental, imaginative and prescient, and listening to companies suppliers.

The final subject regarding associated companies is that the earnings earned by the associated companies are usually not topic to any MLR necessities. Meaning there’s the chance that what seems as prices to the MA plan are partly earnings to the guardian firm that move by means of the associated enterprise. Within the part that follows we summarize what is thought about gross earnings and margins to the guardian corporations sponsoring MA plans, a case examine of the connection between margins and ROA, and a case highlighting the potential function of associated companies or when companies are carved out (as behavioral well being companies typically are).

Prices and Income in MA

Profitability, as measured underneath a particular definition of gross margins,  are reported usually by MedPAC. Margins measure the power of corporations to earn earnings taking account of manufacturing, fastened prices, and depreciation. It doesn’t nevertheless, mirror the return on invested capital, which is an indicator that informs whether or not the funding within the agency represents a very good use of capital relative to different market alternatives. Under we report gross earnings and gross margins for MA plans aggregated to the extent of the guardian firm that sponsors the plans. We place the reported MA margins into context by reporting margins for the Commonplace and Poor’s 500 (S&P 500). The return on belongings (ROA) is one measure of the return to capital. This measure estimates the earnings that an organization generates for each greenback of belongings held. For multi-product corporations that promote throughout enterprise strains just like the 5 largest MA insurers, this requires making asset allocation assumptions which can be considerably arbitrary and require detailed inside knowledge from corporations. These limitations imply that, for essentially the most half, we can’t report ROA statistics for MA plans on the guardian firm degree. Nevertheless, as a result of Humana is taken into account a “pure play in Medicare Benefit,” we’ll examine the margins and the ROA for that firm as an illustration.

We use knowledge from a wide range of sources to tell our evaluation of MA plan efficiency. Publicly traded corporations are required to file a 10-Ok report with the SEC annually, which incorporates detailed monetary statements in addition to different related feedback and knowledge on the efficiency of various strains of enterprise. The IRS Type 990 is the equal report for tax-exempt organizations. Utilizing these paperwork for Humana and Kaiser, respectively, we are able to acquire high-level monetary efficiency data and a few particular details about the efficiency of MA plans.

To complement these knowledge and procure a extra granular understanding of the revenue streams for plans owned by these corporations, we use knowledge from the Mark Farrah Associates’ (MFA) Well being Protection Portal. Most MA plan issuers are required to file a sequence of monetary statements to the Nationwide Affiliation of Insurance coverage Commissioners (NAIC).[2] This features a supplemental exhibit which requires the issuer to submit data on the efficiency of every of their enterprise segments, separating between industrial, MA, Medicaid, and different insurance coverage merchandise.[3] These knowledge embrace detailed income and expenditure data on the plan and guardian degree.

We then use the MFA-cleaned model of the supplemental exhibit to calculate plan earnings and margins for 2018 and 2019. Then, we complement that plan-level knowledge with CMS Medicare Benefit/Half D Contract and Enrollment Information to determine the guardian firm of every plan inside the dataset. Our remaining calculations of earnings and margins are rolled as much as the guardian/12 months degree.

Overview of Margins and Gross Income

Gross earnings and margins for the MA enterprise of program guardian corporations are reported in Desk 1. We report common gross earnings weighted by enrollment for 3 units of guardian corporations: all corporations, the guardian corporations with the ten largest enrollments, and what we discuss with because the “large 5” (United, Humana, CVS/Aetna, Kaiser, and Anthem).

Income, medical loss ratios, and the possession construction of Medicare Benefit plans


Placing the margins reported in Desk 1 into context, we take into account the typical margins throughout the broader market after which particular business averages for 2019. The typical working margin for all industries and corporations was about 11% in 2019. These margins different significantly throughout industries. For instance, meals wholesalers had margins of two.7%, oil and fuel manufacturing 19.9%, data companies 28.3%, and pc companies 7.6%. Considered on this means MA profitability doesn’t stand out amongst U.S. industries. But as we famous earlier, margins give solely a partial image of profitability. Nevertheless, as a result of we can’t make sufficient estimates of a unique view within the type of ROA for MA guardian corporations broadly, we spotlight how margins and ROA might include totally different data that will enable for a extra full perspective.

Humana as a case instance

In 2019, Humana had the second largest share of MA enrollees with 18%, or about 4 million folks, behind solely UnitedHealthcare. MA accounts for about 82% of Humana revenues. It is because of this it’s thought-about a “pure play” in MA. Based mostly on the info extracted from SEC 2019 Type 10-Ok filings and knowledge based mostly on Humana’s NAIC filings, we estimate margins in a few methods. The best estimate takes the “pure play” remark actually utilizing Humana’s complete revenues and complete bills from the SEC filings. We use the reported gross earnings of $3.19 billion and complete revenues of $64.9 billion to acquire an working margin of 4.9%.  Utilizing complete gross earnings utilized to Humana belongings of $29.1 billion, we estimate an ROA of 11.0%. Utilizing the NAIC reporting for Humana’s MA plans reveals a gross revenue from MA of $2.09 billion and complete MA revenues of $49.56 billion for an working margin of 4.2% in 2019. Including additional context, the general ROA for all publicly traded corporations was reported to be 2.55% in 2019. The implication is that Humana’s ROA is excessive relative to the remainder of the S&P 500. The explanations for these variations might contain variation in market energy, accounting practices, or the therapy intangible capital. This implies that neither margins nor ROA alone will present a whole evaluation of profitability.

Associated companies

One query that arises within the debate about whether or not the MLR is prone to constrain overpayments is the diploma to which guardian corporations of MA plans can increase earnings by making use of proudly owning associated companies that aren’t topic to MLR laws. The implication is that earnings to the guardian firm might seem as prices in MLR stories for the MA enterprise. The “large 5” corporations all have associated companies together with PBMs, post-acute suppliers, hospitals, and doctor practices, to call just a few. In every case, the costs charged to the MA plan can have a fabric impact on the place earnings and prices seem. This creates potential to maneuver earnings exterior the attain of laws.

The potential for such habits is illustrated by analyzing the expertise of Kaiser MA plans. Kaiser’s full vertically built-in construction highlights the function of associated companies within the accounts of plans and guardian corporations. Kaiser Permanente is the guardian firm to well being plans, doctor practices, and hospitals. Based on the 2019 annual report, Kaiser had $84.5 billion in revenues in 2019, web earnings of $7.4 billion, and working earnings of $2.7 billion throughout all strains of enterprise. The NAIC filings for MA in 2019 present $5.39 billion in revenues for 2019 that touches a number of plans throughout the nation. The expenditures are reported at $5.42 billion. Thus, earnings had been -$24.6 million for an working margin of -0.5%.  To interpret some of these knowledge requires acquiring data on inside switch costs between the Kaiser Well being Plan and the associated entities owned by the identical guardian firm. The 2019 Type 990 filed by Kaiser stories $15.47 billion in Medicare revenues and complete revenues of $62.24 billion. The Type 990 stories expenditures of roughly $61 billion. Of that complete, practically $39.6 billion was accounted for by contractual funds. The guardian Kaiser Basis Well being Plan lists 5 impartial contractors: Kaiser Basis Hospitals, The Permanente Medical Group, Southern California Permanente Medical group, Hawaii Permanente Medical Group, and Easterseals of Southern California. 4 of the 5 impartial contracts are owned by the guardian firm that owns the Kaiser Basis Well being Plan. The 4 corporations owned by the Kaiser guardian firm account for $43.34 billion {dollars} or 71% of expenditures by the well being plan. Thus, there are vital components of the Kaiser Permanente group whose revenues seem as prices in MLR reporting. For instance, Kaiser hospitals accounted for $20.3 billion in spending by the Kaiser Basis Well being Plan. The Kaiser Basis Hospitals had complete revenues from all sources of $30.4 billion in 2019 and gross earnings of $3.73 billion. Thus, there are substantial transactions between the MA plans and hospitals owned by the guardian firm and subsequently alternatives for web revenues to the guardian firm to be handled as prices to the well being plans that happy MLR necessities.


Most MA enrollees are served by MA plans which can be massive insurers that promote insurance coverage to a number of markets and which have a number of associated and unrelated companies. The associated companies can account from about 20% of spending to as a lot as 71%. The implication is that for the well being plans serving most MA beneficiaries, associated companies provide a chance for pricing practices inside the guardian agency umbrella that may defend earnings from the phrases of MLR laws. The extent to which guardian corporations interact in such practices is but unknown. The potential to interact in such practices places smaller plans with out associated companies at a aggressive drawback. What is evident is that CMS steerage on switch costs and monitoring of MLR reporting is kind of restricted. This will likely change sooner or later because the 2022 fee laws governing MA plans requires renewed efforts to observe reporting linked to MLR laws.

The Brookings Establishment is financed by means of the help of a various array of foundations, firms, governments, people, in addition to an endowment. An inventory of donors might be present in our annual stories revealed on-line right here. The findings, interpretations, and conclusions on this report are solely these of its writer(s) and are usually not influenced by any donation.


[1] In observe, most medical expenditures that depend towards the MLR are claims for medical companies. Nevertheless, expenditures to enhance well being care high quality are additionally included, equivalent to companies meant to advertise wellness or forestall hospital readmission. Administrative prices and earnings do not depend in direction of assembly the MLR.

[2] For the needs of our evaluation, we exclude plans sponsored by life insurers and California HMO plans, which don’t file the supplemental type with the NAIC that breaks out financials by line of enterprise.

[3] The precise MFA knowledge product is the Operations by LOB dataset inside the Well being Protection Portal.